- Gave Conway and Grenier 5 points each for the National Anthem
- Gave Batista, Orton, and Flair 5 points each for interupting the Edge/HHH promo.
- No winner was announced for the Kane/Batista match so I scored it no contest.
- 5 points to Trish and Tyson for guest announcing/prematch promo.
- Separate match points to Trish and Nidia for that quick title defense.
2
wiggs
ID: 55640517 Tue, Jul 06, 2004, 10:15
I scored this last night also and got a couple differences. I could be wrong, but I wanted to bring them up.
1st I have batista with 17 and Flair with 44, I think I know the difference we have, I didnt award him with any points when they came down to interupt edge and HHH because they really didnt do anything.
Edge I have with 30, I think the problem is you gave him 5 for this thing with HHH, In rings are 5 points, not 2 right?
Everything else seems to be the same.
3
Farn
ID: 5564268 Tue, Jul 06, 2004, 11:17
Well, I gave the points to Batista and Flair cause they came down in the group that interupted. Just seemed worthy of 5. But I listed it so people could decide for themselves.
As for Edge, I gave him the 5 points for the interuption of HHH. That's the first 5 in his column. So I am not sure what you are saying as far as a mistake being made.
4
wiggs
ID: 21612611 Tue, Jul 06, 2004, 12:13
sorry Farn, forget the edge thing. For some reason I had his loss as +15 rather then +12. I will just keep my mouth shut now :)
5
Species Leader
ID: 7724916 Tue, Jul 06, 2004, 13:21
I am still in favor of giving somebody like 3-5 points a week for their team if they volunteer to score Snoredown. I feel that's only fair for taking such a brutal job. (btw, you only get 1-3 points if you do it by skimming the post show report.)
I've been doing it lately and don't mind at all. I usually watch the show and it's obviously easier to score a show accurately if you've watched it. But I see two potential issues with me doing the scoring.
First, I also do the standings and stats. I don't mind the extra work, scoring only takes a few minutes unless there's lots of debatable elements, but it's more of a matter of integrity to keep the person doing the scoring seperate from the person tallying the scores. Obviously I trust myself to be fair, but I always liked that we had seperate people doing it as a check/balance measure.
Second, my roster is loaded with Smackdown talent. Again, I trust myself to be fair but if someone was to find a problem with the way I score a show, I don't like the extra potential for anyone to think that I am serving myself any extra points.
That said I have no problem scoring it until someone else who catches the show most weeks finds time and desire to do it.
8
wiggs
ID: 21612611 Tue, Jul 06, 2004, 14:41
I used to score smackdown alot, but lately the mets have been bumping it to a later time, or knocking it off the air completely. I would be willing to score when I see it, but there is no guarantee i will see any particular show.
9
Great One@ Work
ID: 285541612 Tue, Jul 06, 2004, 15:34
I am never home on thursdays or I would give scoring a shot...
10
Species Leader
ID: 7724916 Tue, Jul 06, 2004, 17:15
I would only be doing it from recaps - offering less value.